

On Tuesday, March 17, the Chronicle received an email from a California man named Viral Bhagat, a former employee of META, the owner of Facebook and a number of other well known social media platforms. Bhagat wrote to tell us that Ali Jaffery, the Croton Democrats endorsed nominee for Croton Village Justice, had been sanctioned by a federal court in February for improper conduct. Bhagat attached a copy of the sanctions (see below), and urged the Chronicle to inform its readers about them, arguing that the sanctioned conduct was relevant to Jaffery’s fitness to serve as village justice.
It immediately became clear from the document that Bhagat was the plaintiff in a federal lawsuit in which Jaffery, until last month, had been the attorney for the defendant in the case, another former employee of META named Anu Shah. Right around the time that he contacted us, Bhagat attempted four times to post comments about the matter on stories that the Chronicle had previously done about Jaffery and his electoral race with incumbent Village Justice Sam Watkins.
We deleted those comments from Bhagat, who did not attempt to shield his identity (nor did he ask for anonymity in his email to us), on the grounds that the multiple posting constituted trolling and also that he had made serious allegations against Jaffery which we had not independently confirmed. Both of these features of his comments violated the Chronicle’s comments policy.
At our request, however, Bhagat did provide us with other documents and materials related to the matter. We also learned that Bhagat had contacted leaders of Croton Democrats and other individuals in the village about his claims, and that knowledge that Jaffery had been sanctioned by the court was spreading in the village, especially among local attorneys who obviously take an interest in such matters.
We quickly verified the authenticity of the sanctions document (see below) and began examining the public court docket to understand the history of the case. The public docket (which can be viewed here, although specific documents require a fee-paying service to access) reveals a very messy and bitter lawsuit between two individuals who met on a dating app and subsequently became remote friends and colleagues. Jaffery was the attorney for defendant Shah between June 2025 until last month, when he asked to be relieved as counsel after a dispute with Shah over billing matters. (See below.)
Bhagat’s lawsuit, which was first filed in New York State Supreme Court in February 2024 and later moved to the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, is based on allegations that Shah had misled him into requesting a password reset for an individual whom Shah knew but Bhagat did not. This violated META’s policies, and after investigating the matter, META terminated Bhagat. (The fact that Bhagat at first falsely claimed to know the third party apparently weighed heavily against him.) In the litigation, and elsewhere, Bhagat has made many allegations against Shah, blaming her for his firing and accusing her of dishonesty and other misrepresentations.
In the course of the lawsuit, which as of this writing has 646 docket entries over the roughly two years it has been active, the plaintiff and defendant have engaged in numerous bitter battles over issues of legal discovery (production of relevant documents) which have kept the judge in the case, Valerie E. Caproni, and especially the assigned magistrate judge, Robyn F. Tarnofsky, very busy trying to referee the messy disputes. (A magistrate judge is often assigned to handle day to day matters in a lawsuit.)


The public record suggests that Bhagat, who is representing himself (acting pro se), has demonstrated a very aggressive litigating style; and Jaffery, representing Shah, has been passionate in his defense of his (now former) client. The heat of the litigation may have triggered the improprieties which led to Jaffery being sanctioned by the court.
In late January of this year, an individual identifying themselves as “Steven Greene” wrote to defendant Shah about the lawsuit, offering to aid her with information supposedly relevant to the case. Jaffery, apparently convinced that “Steven Greene” was actually Bhagat using a pseudonym, wrote to Greene’s supposed email address with a copy to Shah, Bhagat, and another individual. The email, dated January 30, read:
“Mr. Bag Hat:
Your emails to and from yourself read like someone with too much time and not enough purpose. Given what we know about your life and finances, you seem to be well-resourced and profoundly under-occupied. Match the money you spent on hair plugs and treat your acne scars so that the hookers don’t immediately throw up in their mouths.”
On February 1, Baghat wrote to Judge Caproni describing Jaffery’s “vulgar, humiliating, and sexually degrading” email and asking for various kinds of legal relief, including sanctions against Jaffery and a referral to the “SDNY Committee on Grievances.” On February 4, the magistrate judge, Robyn Tarnofsky, issued the sanctions described in her order:
Meanwhile, around the same time, a dispute over payment of legal fees broke out between defendant Shah and Jaffery, involving several thousand dollars. Jaffery claimed that Shah had not paid these fees, while Shah countered that in fact she had paid them and that Jaffery’s firm’s accounting department had somehow not credited them. This dispute also spilled onto the public docket, obligating the magistrate judge to issue orders about the conflict. The parties involved now say that the dispute has been resolved, but as a consequence Jaffery asked to be relieved as Shah’s counsel. As we write, Shah is now also defending herself pro se.
Last November, while he was still Shah’s counsel, Jaffery filed a motion for summary judgement in the case, arguing that there were no issues of fact for a jury to decide and that Shah was entitled to have the case dismissed as a matter of law. Jaffery also cited legal precedents indicating that Bhagat was entirely responsible for his own conduct, no matter what Shah had or had not done, and that he was the sole author of his own troubles.
In December, Bhagat filed his opposition to that motion, and included a long list of factual issues that he claimed required a jury to decide. The judge in the case, who would normally be the one to rule on matters of law, has not yet done so, nor has she yet scheduled any hearings on the matter. (A long delay between filing of motions and rulings by judges is typical in most courts.)
Jaffery has declined to respond to a number of questions we asked about these matters, citing the ongoing lawsuit and attorney-client privilege for issues that are not already on the public docket. Jaffery adds that despite Bhagat’s requests that he be brought up before a grievance committee, he has not been disciplined in such a manner.
As for the dispute with his former client, Jaffery told us, “The firm has since amicably resolved all disputes with Ms. Shah and I sincerely wish her the best.”
The Chronicle had scheduled an interview with Shah for this week, but she subsequently cancelled it and asked for a lengthy extension of time that we could not agree to, given that rumors about these matters have already begun circulating widely in the village. Just before publishing, we again had a brief exchange with Shah by email in which we specifically asked her to confirm Jaffery’s statement above; she declined to do so and once again asked for more time to respond so that she could talk to us about “how he deals with his clients.” We will include any statements she eventually makes in an update to this story.
Word about the sanctions against Jaffery has spread rapidly in the village, especially among local attorneys, a number of whom have now seen the sanctions order against Jaffery. We have talked to several of them about what it means for Jaffery’s suitability to be Village Justice. Opinion is divided. While a couple of attorneys were forgiving because of Jaffery’s passionate defense of his client, and pointed out that the sanctions were relatively minor, others said that his crude personal attacks on the plaintiff were unprofessional and troubling.
“He may not have the right temperament to be our village justice,” said one. Another commented: “We all get annoyed in court or on cases, but like a doctor you absolutely need to be able to detach.”
While Jaffery says he is not able to comment on the lawsuit itself, he did provide us with a statement about these incidents, in which he acknowledged the improper conduct for which he was sanctioned. We are publishing it here in full:
To my neighbors:
In local elections, word of mouth travels fast, and I want to address a specific incident from my legal career directly.
I am an employment lawyer. Throughout my career, I have represented people who are going through some of the worst moments of their lives. Recently, I represented a woman who alleged in the litigation that she was the target of a years-long harassment campaign by the opposing party in her case.
Because this individual was representing himself, he was not subject to the ethical rules that apply to attorneys.
In reaction to this conduct targeting my client, on January 30, 2026, I responded to a particular set of e-mails from an anonymous source with harsh rhetoric. Mr. Bhagat reported my response to the presiding judge. When asked about it, I did not make excuses. I accepted full responsibility for my actions and for crossing a line of professional decorum. I was fined $250.00 and required to complete a continuing legal education course, both of which I promptly satisfied. I learned a valuable lesson from this experience: to never use unprofessional language in any communication with anyone no matter the provocation.
My clients are often people who have had their voices stripped away. It is my privilege to vindicate their rights.
We are a nation of laws. As your Village Justice, I will bring my deep respect and understanding of the law to the bench, coupled with the conviction that the legal system should never be used as a tool for abuse.
I am an open book, and if anyone has questions about my record or my career, I welcome the conversation.
Sincerely,
Ali R. Jaffery
*************************************************************************************************************
Editor’s Note: The Chronicle does not endorse candidates for political office. Our role is to serve as a platform for candidates and their supporters to argue their positions, for other community members to express their own opinions, and to report on news and other developments that are relevant to the election and the public’s right to know.
*************************************************************************************************************
To share this post, or to share The Croton Chronicle, please click on these links.
Comments policy: No personal attacks or trolling. Please be polite and respectful at all times.



Some comments have been deleted at the request of the commenter.
And yet our highly competent and respected Judge Watkins, who has likely encountered heated situations hundreds of times during his decades on the court has responded by launching juvenile personal attacks... let me count... never.